derived layer 引入只读 spreading activation shadow path
Evaluation modality
Spec-levelA spec-motivation / governance borrow. Evaluated by spec review + contract tests, not A/B or ablation.
- Primary owner
- —
- Phase-A verdict
- —
- Shadow profile
- —
- Source papers
- Logan 2026 CMA
- Specs
- docs/specs/continuum-memory.mddocs/specs/evaluation.md
Blind spot (现状盲点)
[`docs/specs/continuum-memory.md`](../specs/continuum-memory.md) 已经把 memory owner 内部重分层成 `learned core + artifact store + derived index`,并且 retrieval 已升级为 owner-side learned-core-guided recall。但当前证明面更偏向"统一 recall signal + artifact anchor",对**显式多跳联想召回**的机制描述还不够硬。CMA 的 associative routing 探针显示,spreading activation 能在 query 没有词法重叠时,通过 semantic / temporal / structural edges 找到多跳相关记忆;这正好对应我们 derived layer 未来要承担的"关系图谱 / 聚合索引 / 跨 owner readout"能力。 但这条不能直接做成主路径。CMA 的参考实现允许 retrieval 驱动 graph mutation,如果照搬到 VZ,会带来两个风险:(1) 自由 edge mutation 绕过 `MemoryModule` 唯一 owner;(2) 不受控的 activation feedback loop 导致 memory drift。正确姿势是先做**只读 shadow path**,只用于候选重排和 evidence,不写 durable memory。
Adoptable suggestions (可落地动作)
- 1.在 [`docs/specs/continuum-memory.md`](../specs/continuum-memory.md) 增加 "Read-only Spreading Activation Shadow Path" 小节,明确该路径只属于 derived layer 的 SHADOW 评估,不参与 durable write。PROPOSED
Not a runnable A/B candidate — evaluated by the path above, not ablation.
- 2.定义最小 edge 类型:semantic、temporal(FOLLOWED_BY)、associative、structural(owner-to-owner readout),每条 edge 必须带 provenance。PROPOSED
Not a runnable A/B candidate — evaluated by the path above, not ablation.
- 3.实现 damped propagation:activation 只在 bounded hop 内传播;每次 query 输出 activation trace,作为可审计 telemetry。PROPOSED
Not a runnable A/B candidate — evaluated by the path above, not ablation.
- 4.只允许把 activation 结果用于 retrieval candidate re-ranking;任何新 edge / edge weight 更新都必须经 session-post slow loop + ModificationGate,不能在 turn-time retrieve 中原地写回。PROPOSED
Not a runnable A/B candidate — evaluated by the path above, not ablation.
- 5.与 CMA-2 的 VZ-MemProbe 绑定:只有 shadow path 在 associative recall / disambiguation probe 上有稳定收益,才考虑进入 ACTIVE。PROPOSED
Not a runnable A/B candidate — evaluated by the path above, not ablation.
Traceability
No plugins / runs linked yet. Scaffold a suggestion to start.
Expected benefit (预期收益)
- 给 R5/R6 的"联想记忆"增加可解释、多跳、可审计的工程路径,而不是只依赖向量相似度。 - 在不破坏 R8 SSOT 的前提下,探索 CMA 的 strongest mechanism。 - 为 VZ-MemProbe 的 associative recall / contextual disambiguation 两类测试提供可对照实验组。
Cited paper (引用论文)
**D1. Logan J. *Continuum Memory Architectures for Long-Horizon LLM Agents*. arXiv:2601.09913, 2026.** - 文档位置:[`research/openai-frontier-2026/papers/D1_continuum_memory_architectures.pdf`](../../research/openai-frontier-2026/papers/D1_continuum_memory_architectures.pdf) - 深入分析:[`research/openai-frontier-2026/notes/D1_continuum_memory_deep_analysis.md`](../../research/openai-frontier-2026/notes/D1_continuum_memory_deep_analysis.md) - 摘要原文(精炼): > We define the Continuum Memory Architecture (CMA), a class of systems that maintain and update internal state across interactions through persistent storage, selective retention, associative routing, temporal chaining, and consolidation into higher-order abstractions. ... Preliminary evaluation across four behavioral probes (knowledge updates, temporal association, associative recall, contextual disambiguation) provides initial evidence that CMA-class behaviors yield advantages on tasks that stress memory dynamics. - 关键观点:CMA 的 spreading activation / associative routing 对多跳召回有直接价值;但 VZ 不能照搬 free-form graph mutation,必须先做 read-only shadow path。 ---